\documentstyle[12pt]{article} 

\begin{document}

\title{Minimizing Shortfall Risk Using Duality Approach - An
  Application to Partial Hedging in Incomplete Markets} \author{Mingxin
  Xu, Carnegie Mellon University}

\date{Computational Finance Seminar, March 9}

\maketitle

Option pricing and hedging in a complete market are well-studied with
nice results using martingale theories.  However, they remain as open
questions in incomplete markets. In particular, when the underlying
processes involve jumps, there could be infinitely many martingale
measures which give an interval of no-arbitrage prices instead of a
unique one. Consequently, there is no martingale representation
theorem to produce a perfect hedge. The question of picking a
particular price and executing a hedging strategy according to some
reasonable criteria becomes a non-trivial issue and remains as an open
question.  Follmer and Leukert (2000) proposed an interesting
partial-hedging strategy for European type options to reduce the
initial capital charged while bearing some residual risk. The
optimality criterion for measuring a hedging strategy is to minimize
the shortfall risk at expiration.  Unlike variance minimization, there
is no penalty in case the hedging portfolio overshoots the option
payoff. The existence of the optimal trading strategies when the stock
price follows a semimartingale process is proved in Follmer and
Leukert (2000) using the Neyman-Pearson lemma. However, computations
of these strategies in incomplete models have turned out to be
extremely difficult.

We are interested in doing some explicit computations in a jump
diffusion setting which is widely studied as a typical incomplete
market model.  First we extend the duality results in Kramkov and
Schachermayer (1999) to utility functions which are state dependent
and not necessarily strictly concave in a semimartingale setting and
apply them to the case of shortfall minimization.  This approach not
only gives an alternative way of proving the existence of optimal
solutions, but also gives a structural description of these solutions
which is a generalization of the fact that in a complete market, the
primal optimal terminal portfolio value is a constant times the
marginal utility of the Radon-Nikodym derivative between the risk
neutral measure and the physical measure.  As a small exercise, we
compute the optimal strategy, check the duality relationship and the
HJB equation derived from dynamic programming principle in three
complete market cases.  Next we focus on the more interesting
incomplete market case where we explicitly characterize the primal and
dual sets in terms of the predictable characteristics.  We provide
upper bounds for the value function using duality results.  For lower
bounds, we pick a particular strategy which we call the `bold
strategy'.  Closed-form solutions are given for the case of constant
parameters in the jump diffusion model.  In the cases of bonds and
call options, the upper and lower bounds are quite tight for
reasonable choice of parameters.

\end{document}